NSW Must Plan for Long-Duration Energy Storage in its 2030 Renewables Grid, say Industry Bodies

July 4, 2024

The New South Wales electricity system will be at risk if the government dilutes its own planning for long-duration electricity storage, The Australian Solar Thermal Research Institute (ASTRI) and the Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA) have cautioned in a submission to a consultation on Long Duration Storage by the NSW Government1.

NSW’s Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water is considering changing its definition of long duration storage from 8 hours to 4 hours to help meet legislated targets to have 2GW at 16GWh of storage by 2030. ASTRI and AUSTELA have expressed concern that the change would disincentivise the construction of 12 hour plus storage technologies, which are critical to ensuring the reliability and affordability of NSW’s electricity system as coal is phased out.

ASTRI and AUSTELA advocate consideration of concentrated solar thermal power and storage (CSP) systems, where mirrors capture the sun’s heat and store it in molten salt. The stored heat can then be used, on demand, as required to drive a turbine which generates power, typically for around 15 hours but up to 24 hours in some formats.

Director of ASTRI, Dominic Zaal, said his organisation and AUSTELA had made a joint submission to the Department expressing caution against the proposal to redefine long-duration storage because of the risk it posed to the system, and because changing the definition of LDS would not resolve the challenges that NSW are facing.

“The problem for New South Wales is that in the next decade, three of the four remaining coal-fired power stations will close, and that removes around 70 per cent of the system’s capacity,” said Mr Zaal. “Coal generators cover the overnight electricity market and they are the safety net for renewables’ reliability events. When you build renewable storage to replace coal, 4 hour battery systems are not enough and do not resolve the issue.”

Mr Zaal said the shift in focus away from long-duration intraday storage, to short duration battery storage, is a false economy. While it might help to meet a short-term target, it will ultimately end up costing consumers more because you end up with over investment in short duration storage, at the expense of the longer duration storage the system actually needs. In essence, you pay to defer the problem, but not to actually fix it.

Mr Zaal said the fall-off in commitment to longer duration intraday storage, in excess of eight hours, should be a signal to more accurately incentivise these solutions, rather than reduce the storage benchmark.

“The obvious renewable technologies to cover the retired coal assets in NSW are pumped-hydro and CSP,” said Mr Zaal. “According to CSIRO’s Renewable Energy Storage Roadmap, they are the long-duration intraday storage options that are cheaper than battery at 8 hours, and they have between 12 and 24 hours of storage. They also produce power from synchronous/turbine technology meaning solar thermal and pumped-hydro offer stability services to the system operator.” Mr Zaal said the Department had to be careful how it proceeded because one of the goals of an LDS tender was to incentivise long-duration storage that would otherwise be seen as economically marginal to private capital.

“Battery storage of 2 to 4 hours is already viable with existing market settings. It's the storage systems of over 12 hours, which will be critical to keeping the lights on post-2030, that we need to attract into the system.”

He said AUSTELA and ASTRI believed it was crucial that the LDS definition remained at 8 hours plus, with greater incentive in future tenders to deploy 12 and 15 hour storage in the electricity system.

He said CSIRO’s 2022 Renewable Energy Storage Roadmap, defined 4–12-hour storage as ‘medium’ and 12 – 24 hour storage as ‘long intraday’. In its Levelised Cost of Storage (LCOS) tables, CSIRO also refers to 8 hour storage as ‘medium’.

“This state needs long-duration intraday storage to replace coal generation, and the project owners and their lenders need long-term policy certainty in order to commit to the high costs of deploying it,” said Mr Zaal. “Storage in the 12 – 24 hour range is not cheap, it has long lead-times and it will not be built by the private sector if the framework can be changed unilaterally.”

1 https://www.energy.nsw.gov.au/nsw-plans-and-progress/regulation-and-policy/public-consultations/electricity-infrastructure

Read more

Concentrated solar thermal and eTES offer breakthrough in industrial decarbonisation

Industrial decarbonisation in Australia took a major step forward today after Mars and the Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA) announced a renewable heat project – with concentrated solar thermal (CST) at its heart – at its Mars Petcare Wodonga factory.

Learn more

NSW leading the way on delivering reliable, lowest-cost energy transition with additional long duration storage target: ASTRI and AUSTELA

In a submission to a consultation earlier this year, ASTRI and AUSTELA outlined the importance of 12 hour plus storage technologies to ensure the reliability and affordability of NSW’s electricity system as coal is phased out.

Learn more

AUSTELA and ASTRI response to the NSW Government Review of Long-Duration Storage (Part 6 of the Electricity Infrastructure Investment Act 2020)

The Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA) and the Australian Solar Thermal Research Institute (ASTRI) welcome the opportunity to respond to the NSW Government’s consultation on long-duration storage (LDS).

Learn more

GenCost points to a future made in Australia with solar thermal

Authored by AUSTELA directors Dr Keith Lovegrove, Víctor Marín and Craig Wood

Learn more

GenCost shines light on low-cost of solar thermal to deliver renewable dispatchable capacity to Australian energy system

The Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA) today welcomed the findings in CSIRO’s GenCost report that solar thermal has the lowest levelised cost of energy (LCOE) of any ‘flexible load, low emission’ technology and is cheaper than gas peaking plants and comparable to coal-fired plants.

Learn more

AUSTELA calls for hybrid contracts to recognise generation and storage capabilities of CSP as part of CIS consultation response

The Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA) has outlined changes that will be critical to attract long-duration dispatchable capacity into the National Electricity Market (NEM), in its response to a consultation on the Implementation Design Paper for the Capacity Investment Scheme.AUSTELA welcomed aspects of the Paper, including the merit criteria of ‘system reliability’, ‘delivery of renewable energy’ and ‘additional benefits’.

Learn more

Future looks bright for CST power as decarbonisation focus shifts beyond 2030

A new report from the Australian Solar Thermal Research Institute shows that concentrating solar thermal power has a major role to play in cost-effectively decarbonising electricity, industry and fuels over the short- and long-term.

Learn more

The Australian Concentrating Solar Thermal Value Proposition - Full Report

Concentrated Solar Thermal (CST) uses mirrors to concentrate the sun’s rays to a small area (receiver) to produce medium to high temperature heat (from 150°C up to 1,000°C or beyond). The heat can be used immediately or stored in a Thermal Energy Storage (TES) system- for multiple hours or even days. The heat can be used directly as industrial process heat or further utilised to generate electric power or to drive chemical processes. The report examines the values that CST can provide to Australia across grid connected and remote / off-grid power generation, industrial process heat and green fuels production.

Learn more

Australia an Emerging Market for CSP

With Australia committing to 43% emissions reduction by 2030 and net zero by 2050, attention is increasingly turning to the need for renewables that incorporate long-term energy storage and dispatchability. That is preciselywhat CSP offers.

Learn more

CSP - A Key Technology to Decarbonise the World

This briefing is intended to showcase CSP technology and why it has a key role to play in the energy transition in Australia and all high solar resource countries.

Learn more

The Australian CST Value Proposition Summary

‘The Australian Concentrating Solar Thermal Value Proposition’, commissioned by ASTRI, prepared by engineering firm Fichtner and assisted by ITP Thermal, assesses CST’s role and value across four Australian use cases: grid connected power; remote area power (mining); industrial process heat; and green fuels production.

Learn more

Response to, Commonwealth Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water

The Australian Solar Thermal Industry Association (AUSTELA) responses to, Commonwealth Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water in the Submission Capacity Investment Scheme.

Learn more

Response to Western Australian Department of Mines, Industry Regulation and Safety – Energy Policy WA

The Australian Solar Thermal Industry Association (AUSTELA) shares some recommendations and concerns regarding the Reserve Capacity Mechanism Review Information Paper (Stage 1) and Consultation Paper (Stage2).

Learn more

Key role of solar thermal power in decarbonising Australia

Published in Eco Generation: The CSIRO’s “Renewable Energy Storage Roadmap” has been endorsed by the Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA), particularly its findings that outline the significant role concentrating solar thermal power (CSP or CST) will play in supplying industrial heat and long-duration storage to the nation, writes Gareth Pye.

Learn more

Concentrated solar power is an old technology making a comeback. Here's how it works

Published in the ABC: There was a time, not long ago, when the future of electricity generation looked something like the opening scene of Blade Runner 2049, with endless arrays of mirrors in concentric circles.

Learn more

Batteries won’t cut it – we need solar thermal technology to get us through the night

Published in The Conversation: Australia’s transition to renewables is gathering speed, but there’s a looming problem with storage. We will need much more long-duration storage to get us through the night, once coal and fossil gas exit the system.

Learn more

CSP will provide low-cost clean power to heat-intensive industries and deliver long-duration energy storage

The Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA) has supported the findings of CSIRO’s Energy Storage Roadmap which outlines the significant role that concentrating solar thermal power (often referred to as CSP or CST) will play in supplying industrial heat and long-duration storage.

Learn more

Capacity Investment Scheme a Positive Step Towards Renewables Generating Overnight Electricity, says AUSTELA

Spokesman for the Australian Solar Thermal Industry Association (AUSTELA), Dr Keith Lovegrove, has welcomed the Energy Ministers’ announcement of a Capacity Investment Scheme which has the potential to address the lack of long-duration storage for renewable energy.

Learn more

AUSTELA Releases 'Solar At Night' Energy Market Policy Brief: Renewable energy policy must incentivise and reward projects based on MWh capacity, not simply MW.

Australia’s future energy system requires a substantial increase in long-duration renewable storage but it must be measured in megawatt/hours for it to strengthen the electricity grid, according to the Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA).

Learn more

Solar at Night

Solar at night Director of the Australian Solar Thermal Research Institute, Dominic Zaal, offers a deep dive into the capabilities of concentrated solar thermal technology, including what has been proven by global projects so far and how the all important Power Purchasing Agreements stack up.

Learn more

Australia Being Left Behind in Renewable Storage Race as Global Industry Prepares for Next Phase of Solar Technology at US Conference

Australia’s future electricity system must include zero-emissions energy storage that can be dispatched overnight to urgently replace retiring coal power plants, ASTRI has warned as it attends the industry’s international conference, SolarPACES.

Learn more

‘Solar At Night’ Project Resolves Grid’s Storage Gap

A campaign has been launched to ensure Australia’s future energy system includes the multiple hours of daily storage required for users to have access to reliable energy solutions overnight.

Learn more

Capacity Mechanism must incentivise investment in dispatchable renewable electricity that can generate overnight

Australia’s future energy system must include renewable power generators that can be dispatched for 12 or more hours, to meet Australia’s zero-emissions overnight power needs.

Learn more

ASTRI and AUSTELA joint statement on the capacity mechanism

The Australian Solar Thermal Research Institute (ASTRI) and the Australian Solar Thermal Energy Association (AUSTELA) welcome the Energy Security Board’s (ESB) discussion paper on the capacity mechanism.

Learn more
Web Design

How to earn a living being a web designer at Finsweet

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat.

Learn more
Web Design

How to earn a living being a web designer at Finsweet

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat.

Learn more
Web Design

How to earn a living being a web designer at Finsweet

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat.

Learn more